Friday, August 11, 2017

Contra Grant On Exaggerated Differences. An article by Adam Grant called Diffe…

Instapundit » Blog Archive » SLATE STAR CODEX: Contra Grant On Exaggerated Differences. An article by Adam Grant called Diffe…:
"An article by Adam Grant called Differences Between Men And Women Are Vastly Exaggerated is going viral, thanks in part to a share by Facebook exec Sheryl Sandberg.
It’s a response to an email by a Google employee saying that he thought Google’s low female representation wasn’t a result of sexism, but a result of men and women having different interests long before either gender thinks about joining Google.
Grant says that gender differences are small and irrelevant to the current issue.
I disagree. . . .
...In the year 1850, women were locked out of almost every major field, with a few exceptions like nursing and teaching.
Image result for explain thisThe average man of the day would have been equally confident that women were unfit for law, unfit for medicine, unfit for mathematics, unfit for linguistics, unfit for engineering, unfit for journalism, unfit for psychology, and unfit for biology.
He would have had various sexist justifications – women shouldn’t be in law because it’s too competitive and high-pressure; women shouldn’t be in medicine because they’re fragile and will faint at the sight of blood; et cetera.
As the feminist movement gradually took hold, women conquered one of these fields after another. 51% of law students are now female. 
So are 49.8% of medical students, 45% of math majors, 60% of linguistics majors, 60% of journalism majors, 75% of psychology majors, and 60% of biology postdocs.
Yet for some reason, engineering remains only about 20% female.
And everyone says “Aha! I bet it’s because of negative stereotypes!”
This makes no sense.
There were negative stereotypes about everything!
Somebody has to explain why the equal and greater negative stereotypes against women in law, medicine, etc were completely powerless, yet for some reason the negative stereotypes in engineering were the ones that took hold and prevented women from succeeding there..."
Read it all!

No comments: